Home Your Page Browse / Search Films Articles / Lists Reviewers About the Site


In The Cut
 
Year : 2003
Country : United-States


p r e f e r r e d   r e v i e w e r s :

You haven't selected any preferred reviewers. To learn more about customizing your experience, click here.

o t h e r   r e v i e w e r s :

Emmitt  [ 7.0 ]    [ add to preferred ]

pretty good one with meg ryan ,mark ruffalo and others. nice thriller.

TheMovieGuy  [ 8.5 ]    [ add to preferred ]

Actors-Meg Ryan, Mark Ruffalo, Jenifer Jason Leigh

Plot-Frannie(Ryan) is a sexually frustrated english teacher. A brutal murder is commited in her neihborhood. A detective(Ruffalo) questions her. They soon begin a steamy affair and as the murders pile up, she begins to grow increasingly suspicious of him and every other man she knows.

Review-When I first heard about this movie months before its release I was pretty excited. It sounded interesting and sounded like a total turn around for Ryan. I heard it was based on a critically aclaimed book. I quickly ran out a got it. After reading it it hugley lowered my expectations for the movie. The book was just slow. annoying and too sexually explicit. Now yes the movie is too but nothing like the book. Usually that stuff doesnt bother me but this was too much. When I read the reviews I decided I still wanted to see it just for Ryans preformance and for the dreamlike directing. I wasn't dissapointed, in fact I was surprised. Meg Ryan gives a wonderful preformance here in here most unglamous role to date. She was very believable. Also, Jane Campions directing is incredible. She creates a spooky dream-like feeling and keeps an ongoing sense of dread throughout. Now this movie is not for everyone. It is not much of a movie to see for entertainment value. It is slow and deppressing. It is a movie for people who apreciate good film making. It is loaded with symbolism and hidden meanings and themes. In fact the whole murder mystery is almost kept in the backround. This is a movie about people and the darker side of human nature. Many people will go see this either for Meg Ryans nude scenes or to see a thriller. Well there is only a little of each of those. See it for the film making or don't see it.

Rating- R for strong sexuality including explicit dialogue, nudity, graphic crime scenes and language

Dancing_P  [ 4.5 ]    [ add to preferred ]

There should be a lot going on here: In the Cut meshes Jane Campion's arthouse sensibilities with a dark, gritty neo-noir story that messes with genre AND gender conventions. It also features rom-com queen Meg Ryan in a dark and emotionally trying role miles away from her usual shtick. Yet for all it promises, In the Cut only superficially delivers. It's an erotic drama in which a none-too-welcome whodunit is forced; alternately, it's a crime procedural where people can't seem to stop fucking. The result is a gloomy yet empty film, Breillat meets Bogart in music video form.

Meg Ryan plays Frannie, an inner-city English teacehr who may or may not have witness a murder in a seedy bar. She's interrogated by fiery cop Mark Ruffalo only to find herself in a tumultuous affair with him and his comically unnecessary mustache.

Throughout the film, Campion seems ill at ease with the more seedy aspects of the story; it's as if she can't quite acceot the generic trappings of the story, which makes that whole angle severely glossed over. Unfortunately, it's structured more as a mystery than an erotic drama; the overall effect is distanced and cold. It's a damn shame because there are a ton of little nuances for Campion to sink her teeth into that are flattened out in the end product.

chapter11  [ 4.0 ]    [ add to preferred ]

Pornish art-thriller wavers between art-house psych-out and grisly thriller. And it works better as a grisly thriller, hinting at enormous potential with an atmosphere pregnant with dread, as evidenced by a tense and heartbreaking discovery of a murder victim and a decent, if "Silence of the Lambs"-y, ending. And Jane Campion could have worked out all the women's issues she wanted to (again, "Silence"-style) and it could have been a fine thriller. Unfortunately, "In the Cut" is intent to cast Meg Ryan in a sex drama about the relationships between women and men interwoven with inspired crime drama elements, inspired photography (if occasionally a bit Nine Inch Nails video-ish), and less-than-inspired freakiness with scruffy 70s-cop-show refugee Mark Ruffalo. I dunno. Maybe all the psychological, intellectual aspects of "In the Cut" went over my head. Still, I can't help thinking that "In the Cut" was less an inspired psychodrama and more a chance to de-cute-ify Meg Ryan by getting her naked in EVERY FREAKING SCENE.

scottwblack  [ 7.0 ]    [ add to preferred ]

Disquieting, New York City-set psychosexual thriller that succeeds despite a familiar storyline thanks to the chemisty between leads Meg Ryan and Mark Ruffalo and the film's palpable sense of menace.

Verbal  [ 4.0 ]    [ add to preferred ]

Campion's second straight misfire. If you want to see Campion's skills on celluloid then stick with The Piano. The problem here is exactly what TheMovieGuy was referring to: its mashing of genres makes for a sluggish ride of questionable logic to its inevitably perfunctory conclusion.

Ultimately, the film suffers from a case of Generic Thriller Plotting Techniques.

**Spoiler** (I suppose...?)
To me, including the subpar thriller aspect is used simply to arouse further doubt regarding the intentions of Ruffalo's character, but there seemed to be enough of a story between Ryan, Ruffalo and Leigh's characters to warrant a serious drama.

astrosheil  [ 3.0 ]    [ add to preferred ]

Please, can we have the Meg Ryan of Sleepless in Seattle back? Despite the talented actors and director, I thought this movie was a cut above real porn.

jeff_v  [ 1.5 ]    [ add to preferred ]

An unqualified disaster. Campion is one of the most pretentious filmmakers working today, and In the Cut builds toward some muddled feminist statement while slumming about in genre clothing. Meg Ryan slums about sans clothing in a boring performance that only left me marveling how jacked-up she looks thanks to plastic surgery. Neither her character nor any of the others are believable. The story could have ended any number of ways because there's nothing the characters could do that would be surprising. The story is riddled with red herrings and artificial props to keep it running. (Ask yourself, why didn't Meg Ryan's character say something about the tattoo earlier? The only answer is because we wouldn't have this stupid movie if she did.) Campion's style is distracting and seemingly arbitrary, with a smeared-lens look and unmotivated perspective changes.

swblack   [  7.0  ]
Corto   [  8.0  ]

 
Weighted Rating : 5.9
No. Ratings : 10
No. Reviews : 8


Log in to review this film


Search:




Ranked by Rating
 
2003 # 299
2000's # 3469
All-time # 17715



Ranked by No. Ratings
 
2003 # 59
2000's # 355
All-time # 1461
 


[ oofnet feedback ]