Home Your Page Browse / Search Films Articles / Lists Reviewers About the Site


Walk the Line
 
Year : 2005
Country : United-States


p r e f e r r e d   r e v i e w e r s :

You haven't selected any preferred reviewers. To learn more about customizing your experience, click here.

o t h e r   r e v i e w e r s :

Cookeyface  [ 10.0 ]    [ add to preferred ]

Great film with great actors. Reese and Joaquin have great chemistry together as Johnny Cash and June Carter Cash. In my opinion, truly underappreciated film at many award shows in 2005.

Dancing_P  [ 7.5 ]    [ add to preferred ]

I'm starting to wonder if there's really a satisfying way to make a biopic like this without making it some eight hours long. It's true that Walk the Line is fairly unoriginal in terms of delivery; if you've seen a music biopic before, there's a good chance it looked a lot like this. Walk the Line's strongest points, therefore, are not in the narrative but in the performances and in the music. I grew up with Johnny Cash playing in my house every Saturday and Sunday morning; I used to make fun of my dad for listening to 'cowboy music' but when I moved out, I realised I missed it. I suppose this also factors in setting Walk the Line apart from movies like Ray and its ilk; your enjoyment of the music will go a long way to your enjoyment of the film. Starting from his childhood on a cotton plantation (where his older brother Jack is killed and the blame is put on young J.R.) and ending in 1968 with his marriage to June Carter (Reese Witherspoon), it's the story of a strange young man who came to be known around the world as the man in black. Substance abuse, unhappy marriages, demons, paternal love problems, jail time and Jerry Lee Lewis: all the elements are here. Where the film truly shines, however, is in the musical sequences. Phoenix and Witherspoon sing all the songs and play the instruments; the result is not always 100% convincing (depending on the song), but it also lifts the movie from a simple impersonation to an interpretation. Phoenix may not sound exactly like Johnny Cash but at least he doesn't sound like he's trying too hard and failing painfully. He never turns Cash into a parody, no small feat considering how iconic Cash's voice and image are. The songs are terrific and boisterously performed; odds are you'll come out of there singing Ring of Fire for the rest of the day.

chapter11  [ 7.0 ]    [ add to preferred ]

A good film, certainly, if far too standard in plot and direction to be a truly great one. I'm enthralled by Phoenix and Witherspoon, of course-- they're just as good as i'd hoped they'd be-- but between this, and "Ray," and "the Temptations," and "That Thing You Do!" and every episode of VH1's "Behind the Music" ever made, i'm tired of this damn story and direction. Great music, passionately performed, but boring to a fault.

BILOXIBECKY  [ 6.5 ]    [ add to preferred ]

It's great to hear the music, but the film left a lot to be desired. I never forgot that I was watching Phoenix & Witherspoon playing Cash & Carter, and that they were only lip-syncing to some great music. Entertaining, but not really satisfying.

jim  [ 9.0 ]    [ add to preferred ]

Joaquin Phoenix and Reese Witherspoon are so good as Johnny Cash and June Carter that it's possible at tunes to forget you're watching a dramatization and not a documentary. Not only are Phoenix and Witherspoon convincing in the dramatic scenes, but they sing well enough to avoid embarrassing themselves.

astrosheil  [ 8.0 ]    [ add to preferred ]

Incredible performances by Phoenix and Witherspoon make this movie special. With any other pair it would have been a soap opera.

DokBrowne  [ 8.5 ]    [ add to preferred ]

As good as any biopic and given that extra flavor by way of Cash's terrific music (performed impeccably by Joaquin Phoenix). Falls short of greatness because it too closely resembles last year's formulaic (yet strong) "Ray", and anyway, it doesn't bring enough of an edge, or unique vision, to the slideshow display of Cash's big life moments. Nonetheless, it's a supremely enjoyable slideshow, not just for the effortlessly perfect and soulful performances of Phoenix and Reese Witherspoon (who also has an unexpectedly wonderful singing voice), but also for the fun story (pre-drug problems, there's a mythological coolness to seeing Jerry Lee Lewis, Elvis, and Roy Orbison on the road with Cash), the lovely art direction (I know, in a movie like this that's a moot point, but the outdoor scenery is gorgeous and the look of the movie is luminous), the music (although I missed hearing some of my preferred favorites, not that I blame the movie for it), and most of all, the troubled yet ultimately ideal relationship between Johnny and June. I felt an overwhelming sense of goodwill for them as the movie closed, and whether that's germaine to its artistic quality or not is irrelevant; it was a special sensation that the movie stirred in me, and I will cherish it.

To that end, as an ode to their love, I think the movie works a lot better than as a kaleidoscopic look at Cash's legendary career

jeff_v  [ 5.0 ]    [ add to preferred ]

When I die, I want my life story turned into a complex award-delivery system for other people. That's really the ultimate compliment, isn't it?

I didn't get that vibe from the actors, who do their best. (Joaquin Pheonix is probably tired of being asked whether he tapped into his feelings about Rivers' death for the role, but the desperate stench of redemption emanates from him onscreen.) The story gives you nothing to chew on, though. All you have to take home with you is the music, and I could've done just as well sitting at home listening to my Johnny Cash records. A good biopic will find a middle ground between Capote's droning on one particular subject and Walk the Line's glance at a life's greatest hits.

shanster   [  7.5  ]
dayfornight   [  5.5  ]
Wizard   [  5.0  ]
youngg8578   [  7.5  ]
swblack   [  6.0  ]
scottwblack   [  5.5  ]
brian   [  8.0  ]
Corto   [  5.5  ]

 
Weighted Rating : 6.9
No. Ratings : 16
No. Reviews : 8


Log in to review this film


Search:


IMDB Link




Ranked by Rating
 
2005 # 61
2000's # 655
All-time # 4166



Ranked by No. Ratings
 
2005 # 5
2000's # 146
All-time # 685
 


[ oofnet feedback ]