Home Your Page Browse / Search Films Articles / Lists Reviewers About the Site


Duets
 
Year : 2000
Country : United-States


p r e f e r r e d   r e v i e w e r s :

You haven't selected any preferred reviewers. To learn more about customizing your experience, click here.

o t h e r   r e v i e w e r s :

DokBrowne  [ 8.5 ]    [ add to preferred ]

The first notes of the movie are sketchy and disorganized. We glimpse distractedly into giant-head, weird-mouth Scott Speedman’s (Billy) childhood, laugh at and sympathize with harried salesman Paul Giamatti (Todd, who suffers from Edward Norton’s Fight Club complexion of being so jaded that he rarely knows what city he’s in), and in the only suggestion of karaoke, we watch Huey Lewis (Ricky Dean) panhandle a sedated Lochlyn Munro and win the contest at some bar. The cherry to top off this messy preamble is the absence of the movie’s only marketed star, Gwyneth Paltrow, whose overdue introduction 20 minutes later is at first unflattering: as Liv, she’s a ditz, surprisingly, and her earlier moments echo Mira Sorvino’s good-natured, dopey prostitute in Mighty Aphrodite, until Paltrow’s penchant for gentle tenderness, as well as the charming vulnerability of her character, completely hypnotizes you, and you start to notice the wonderful nuance and believability she infuses into this rather forgettable-seeming pit-stop in her career. Plus she doesn’t change her voice to a screechy artificial tone a la Sorvino, so the comparison ends there. If Woody Allen can coax from the Academy an award for such a simplistic caricature (and it’s no secret how capriciously nutty the Best Supporting Actress category winners can be), then surely Paltrow deserves some credit for her infinitely more appealing and complicated performance here.

One of the movie’s fundamental errors is its segregation of the plot lines, right down to (and straight past) the very end. It takes about a half-hour for the actors to pair off on their road trip to the Omaha karaoke championship, where the grand prize is $5,000 (not a tidy sum anymore, but clearly these people aren’t after financial prominence; they want to express themselves, to redefine who they are, and their coupling – Ricky Dean with daughter Liv, Billy with pretty Maria Bello (Suzi), and most touchingly Andre Braugher (Reggie) with Todd – are more focal than the big prize, manifested at greatest clarity when you think back and realize who actually wins at the Omaha contest). Despite that the use of a gallery ensemble – thereby avoiding the single, constricted precedent that would result from having only one primary lead propel the story – gives the plot more ideas and a broader perspective of the theme, the lives of these six wayward souls never meaningfully intersect. Reggie and Todd may coexist with the others in the same room for the climax, but neither their relationship nor their joint quest overlap into those of Ricky Dean-Liv or Billy-Suzi. The thesis of the movie weaves everyone together well enough, but in the tradition of, say, “Seinfeld”, they all should have converged more literally during the final scenes. Having them all appear at the same contest for the same reasons just doesn’t seem sufficient in wrapping all these people together for one unified conclusion. And the haphazard suggestions of a Liv-Billy romance (what about Suzi?) at the end demand a better explanation

There is a good consistency with Billy, though he’s arguably the flattest among the ensemble (could this have any symbolic correlation to Speedman’s abstinence from doing any karaoke singing of his own?). In most movies, the moral character who repeatedly urges others to do right tends to come off as an overbearing Mother Teresa pest, but we understand why Billy does it: growing up he wanted to be a priest. That aspiration fell through at some point in his life (and it seems true of most of the movie’s characters that their lives are wasting away in ways they didn’t plan), but the need to help and guide people still lingers strongly in his conduct and relationships with others. He has a key moment in which he explains how he’s always going to see life as something beautiful no matter how angry and depressed people get, or how negative the collective attitude becomes. It’s spoken during a standard-issue scene where the confident one suddenly gets nervous at the last minute and must be rejuvenated by the person who never seemed to have the faith in the first place, but it complements the character of Billy nicely, and says something profound about life in general that too few people can comprehend or appreciate these days.

Paul Giamatti, one of those many underrated Hollywood types, makes a comeback at last – and not only is he returning to fine form, but he’s finally given a lead role, so he gets to expand on the hilarious psychotic he played in Private Parts and actually do some serious business. Remembered fondly as Pig Vomit and the similarly profane hostage victim in The Negotiator, as well as his modest parts in Jim Carrey movies (Man on the Moon and The Truman Show), he’s unfairly been accused by some of veering into histrionics, but did anyone dismiss Peter Finch’s unforgettable lunacy in Network as such, or Jack Nicholson in One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest? Being energetic and over-the-top is not equivalent to theatrical affectation. Giamatti winds up relatively subdued as Todd, his explosions in Private Parts considered, but his delirious tantrums – aside from being stunningly entertaining – are reconciled by his softer moments of introspection and amused self-loathing. He’s amazing, the second (and overall strongest) of three Oscar-worthy performers to emerge from Duets.

Also good (on the checklist of both acting and singing) – the still blooming Maria Bello (this is quite an improvement, though not much of a personality change, over her last role, circa Coyote Ugly) and Paul Giamatti, the latter taking it less seriously by not trying to hide his regular-Joe voice; in so doing; he shows more soul than everyone else who’s heard throughout the movie, with one mighty exception: Andre Braugher, whose voice was synthesized over the track with that of a professional. Regardless of – or thanks to – this footnote, Braugher’s first duet with Giamatti is terrific, and he absolutely stops the entire show for his rendition of Lynyrd Skynyrd’s “Free Bird” at the end, a performance that’s so equally mesmerizing on both acting and singing levels, and that so beautifully consummates his and Giamatti’s arc (yes, I cried), that Braugher deserves to have the Supporting Actor Oscar handed to him on rose petals and a satin carpet just for that scene. In addition to being the most emotionally stirring moment in the movie, it’s also one of the best scenes I’ve seen in any movie this year. Braugher makes every moment of his screen time count, and because of the awesome perfection to which he and Giamatti’s character are played, Reggie and Todd are ultimately the heart of the movie. Color theirs the most poignant and heartfelt relationship of the year

As for Gwyneth’s singing, she had a hint of Sarah McLachlan, sounding more feminine and high-pitched, but beautiful both times she hits the stage. I’d take her over all the wannabe-divas (Britney, Christina, Mandy, and oldies Whitney, Madonna, and Mariah) flooding the trend mill these days. She’s so unexpectedly talented that one of the first things I did when I returned home after the movie was log on to Napster and download her tracks from the movie (feeling only slight dissatisfaction afterward at being deprived of WATCHING the gorgeous Paltrow sing). As a fellow singer-actress, Jennifer Lopez has nothing on Gwyneth

However, the movie overcompensates for the vocal talents of Huey Lewis, I think. Each of his songs are met with shocked gazes of revelation – "damn, this guy is better than anyone here ever has been, is, or will be!", you can intuit from their expressions. For a man who can easily carry a tune but whose scratchy signing inflections leave something to be desired, and whose real-life popularity has been pretty mum since the early ‘90s, you wouldn’t think he’d be treated as such a phenomenon, but there must be something about him that draws in the crowd – maybe because he’s singing live and in-person, the sight of his huge head and distended, pseudo-Kramer ‘do matched with his ruggedly old, Sean Connery "aged-well-like-fine-wine" appearance is an irresistible attractant. Despite my fairly unkind words, and although (based on his age and current status) I doubt he’s trying to make that ever-more a la mode transition from music to movies (that he cameo’d in Back to the Future as the band tryout supervisor with the bullhorn can’t be considered a valid entrée unto cinema, although he couldn’t have chosen a better movie in which to participate), he still debuts with an impressive sense of dignity. Maybe it’s just that older actors have a distinct advantage in being able to convey wisdom and nobility with barely more than a long pause in dialogue (the best of this acting style still being the master Morgan Freeman, so credible, sympathetic, and stately in all his roles – even in Hard Rain – that his turn as President in Deep Impact was more convincing than just about every actual chief executive that has yet to grace the Oval Office), but Lewis already feels like a venerable pro. Unfortunately for the first half of the movie, his Ricky Dean the Karaoke Hustler Who Gets Stuck With a Daughter He Didn’t Know He Had is a jerk, alternately ignoring and pushing away the sweet familial longings of Liv until that inevitable slap in the face he gets. Then he’s a great guy. Hurray for Huey!

One surreal song selection that would have given Duets endless bonus points: Huey Lewis warbling “The Power of Love,” with his backup crew, The News, somehow coming to his aide. It’s disappointing that one of his signature songs, and, more significantly, the most quintessential ‘80s aria, is sacrificed for a series of bland ditties (okay, so Eurythmics’ “Sweet Dreams” and Sinatra’s “Strangers in the Night” ain’t so bad), but overall it’s easy to forgive all the chosen karaoke songs in this movie for being mediocre in the first place, because the emphasis is on how these non-singers (and yes, we’re supposed to perceive even Lewis as a common guy who just happens to sing like a professional) perform them, and what this means. It was a wiser decision, I believe, that director Bruce Paltrow stuck with a serious tone for the karaoke scenes – aiming only a couple jokes at the expense this oft-ridiculed art – for it would be inappropriate and superficial for the movie to simply mock it the whole time. What dad Paltrow does is reassert the basic philosophy of karaoke, and give it the dramatic parallel it’s been asking for for so long from any medium: that by getting up on a stage in a bar full of people wanting a good time and embarrassing yourself by aping popular songs, you are achieving a certain freedom and flowing expression. Karaoke is your soundtrack of life. It is a virtual replay of something that has happened before, identifying and squashing the proxy and emptiness of that which has either lost its meaning or requires change. By putting all your soul – however clumsy or awkward-sounding it ends up being – into singing one of your favorite songs before a group of your peers, you are releasing emotions and thoughts that need some breathing room, some that you would otherwise be incapable of revealing, of venting. Like these characters, each of whom takes a vacation (usually permanent, in one case only temporary) from their insubstantial lives, the karaoke singer is letting go of some things sacred – his privacy and his inner being – and communicating with himself. And in the process of personal growth, he moves on, nourishing a brighter understanding of where he’s headed…

jeff_v  [ 1.0 ]    [ add to preferred ]

It's official. DokBrowne has the worst taste in film imaginable.

Stitch  [ 8.0 ]    [ add to preferred ]

In defense/support of my fellow movie reviewer, DokBrowne, I must say I really enjoyed this movie as well. I will admit that it is a tad simplistic and there are no great performances here (Andre Brougher not withstanding), but it is still a very enjoyable two hours. The story threads that eventually come together are all entertaining, but my favorite was the the "on-the-lam" story of Todd, a man who has just walked out on his life and an ex-con hitchhiker he picks up. Watching Todd unleash in Karaoke and the acapella rendition of FreeBird at the end are two wonderfully emotional scenes. (Yes, I too shed a few tears). Gwenyth Paltrow has a surprisingly small role for all that she is given top billing, and I was pleasantly surprised that she can sing. Huey Lewis is good as her distant father and I always love watching him perform. The blossoming romance between Gwenyth and Scott Speedman was a nice idea but it just seemed a bit tacked on, like they ran out of time in the movie to tell all the story that needed telling. Oh well, these are minor complaints. It's worth seeing. A nice little film.

Love_Spoon  [ 5.0 ]    [ add to preferred ]

Duets intersects the lives of six people a la Friends through the magic of karaoke singing. It's another film that gives you one idea by seeing the previews, only to delete it and hand you another when you actually watch the film. The music was pretty good, but as far as the story goes, as Alice once said, "Curiouser an curiouser." Paul Giamatti's character, a suburbanite salesman, goes off the deep end and enjoys a crime and karaoke spree with Andre Braugher, and that's just a third of the movie. I have no idea who I would recommend this movie to. Didn't like it, didn't dislike it.

NYCritic  [ 1.5 ]    [ add to preferred ]

Absolutely horrible. I feel so bad for Gwenyth(she was definetly miscast). This film has a wobbly plot and the singing is enough to make your ears bleed. Some advice Ms. Paltrow: Stick to acting!

chapter11  [ 4.5 ]    [ add to preferred ]

DokBrowne, i adore your review immensely, even if i don't care much for the actual film.

Here's the thing: I actually work as a karaoke host, so I'm pretty steeped in the world of karaoke and the singers' culture that springs up from it. And I've been hoping for the longest time that someone would dramatize and film this slice of my world, because there's a way to illustrate this world onscreen without dismissing or aggrandizing it. Unfortunately, "Duets" simply isn't that movie. It's a ham-fisted multi-character dramedy without much going for it, really; and it's not about the obvious ways that the film's mythologizing of karaoke differs from what I see daily, although yeah, that's something I take away from it. It's that the film is too mannered, too simplistic; there _is_ a certain release for dedicated karaoke singers that "Duets" simply doesn't capture. Hell, this precise plot could have worked with a bit of verve and panache, but it simply lays there like a cold fish.

This, of course, is excepting Andre Braugher and Paul Giamatti's little section of the story. That little fragment of the narrative hits all the right notes - they sing wonderfully together (or, well, Giamatti sings beautiful duets with Braugher's voice-over), have remarkable chemistry, and act as if their lives depended on it. Unfortunately, that's a mere third; ultimately, what bugs me about "Duets" is not what it is, but what it isn't. And what it isn't is deserving to be the only real movie about karaoke culture out there.

Verbal   [  3.5  ]
youngg8578   [  7.0  ]

 
Weighted Rating : 5.6
No. Ratings : 8
No. Reviews : 6


Log in to review this film


Search:




Ranked by Rating
 
2000 # 461
2000's # 3850
All-time # 19156



Ranked by No. Ratings
 
2000 # 102
2000's # 488
All-time # 1937
 


[ oofnet feedback ]